Planning Your Dream Retirement in South Africa, How Much Do You Need

As a general guideline, South Africans need to replace at least 75% of their final income upon retirement to maintain a comfortable lifestyle. However, achieving this target is challenging for most households and can be jeopardized by early withdrawals through the newly introduced two-pot system.

Dream Retirement in South Africa

There is no universal retirement savings amount for all South Africans, but experts have offered guidance on how to save effectively for retirement.

Allan Gray’s Recommendation
Twanji Kalula from Allan Gray suggests that to retire comfortably, South Africans should aim to replace at least 75% of their final income. To achieve this, individuals should save between 12% and 17% of their earnings from the beginning of their working lives.

Ninety One’s Study
A study by asset manager Ninety One emphasized the importance of choosing the right initial income level for retirement. Their recommendations include:

• Starting Income Level: Draw no more than 5% of your retirement capital.
• Capital Lump Sum: Save a lump sum equal to 20 times your final salary to invest in an income-generating annuity upon retirement.

By drawing only 5% annually, retirees can expect inflation-adjusted income for up to 30 years, helping ensure financial security throughout retirement.

Target Retirement Savings for South Africans

Research from Just South Africa indicates that the average household requires over R7 million to retire comfortably, based on an annual household income of R300,000.

The Current Retirement Landscape

Unfortunately, many South Africans are not prepared for retirement. According to FNB’s Retirement Insights Survey, nearly 50% of respondents lack a retirement plan. Allan Gray’s data shows that the average South African retiree is only able to replace 31% of their pre-retirement income, and just 9% manage to replace 80% or more.

The Two-Pot Retirement System

In response to these challenges, the South African government introduced the two-pot retirement system in September to help individuals preserve their retirement savings while offering some flexibility.

• Retirement Pot: Two-thirds of contributions are allocated to a retirement pot, which cannot be accessed before retirement.
• Savings Pot: One-third goes into a savings pot, which allows one withdrawal per tax year.
• Vested Pot: For those with existing retirement savings, a separate vested pot holds contributions made before September 1, 2024.

Withdrawal Guidelines

While the savings pot allows for annual withdrawals, financial experts caution against this. Withdrawing funds early can significantly reduce retirement savings, interrupting the compounding growth necessary for long-term financial security.

Example: The Impact of Withdrawals

Allan Gray’s Belinda Carbutt provided an example to illustrate the potential impact of withdrawals on retirement savings.

Siphokazi Kumalo’s Scenario:

• Initial Balance: As of 31 August 2024, Siphokazi’s pension balance was R100,000.
• Vested Component: This amount was moved into her vested component as of 1 September 2024.
• Savings Component: R10,000, or 10% of the total, was allocated to her savings component, available for withdrawal.

Moving forward, one-third of her future retirement contributions will go to her savings pot, and two-thirds to her retirement pot. For example, if she contributes R3,000 per month, R1,000 goes to savings, and R2,000 goes to retirement. If Siphokazi chooses to withdraw, she can do so once per year with a minimum withdrawal of R2,000, though taxes will be deducted at her marginal tax rate.

Comparing Outcomes: No Withdrawals vs. Annual Withdrawals

A comparison between two scenarios over 30 years shows that:

• High Road (No Withdrawals): Siphokazi would have 53% more in retirement savings, six times more cash at retirement, and an effective tax rate of 11%.
• Low Road (Annual Withdrawals): With annual withdrawals, she would have less savings, less cash at retirement, and a higher effective tax rate of 31%.

Summary of Key Benefits

Carbutt highlighted three major benefits of avoiding early withdrawals:

1. Compounding Growth: Siphokazi’s retirement savings would be 53% higher by allowing them to grow without interruption.
2. Larger Cash Portion: If Siphokazi avoided early withdrawals, she would receive six times more in cash at retirement.
3. Tax Savings: By staying the course, Siphokazi would benefit from a lower effective tax rate, paying significantly less in taxes compared to regular withdrawals.

In conclusion, while the two-pot system provides some flexibility, maintaining a disciplined approach to savings and avoiding early withdrawals is key to maximizing long-term retirement outcomes.

Click the link to know more